Rob Davidoff has a degree in Mechanical Engineering with a concentration in Aerospace. Which makes me proud since he says my Atomic Rocket website inspired him to try for a career in rocketry. Currently he is printing turbines for GE Power. I had mentioned his alternate history Eyes Turned Skyward which I awarded the Atomic Rocket Seal of Approval.
Anyway, one fine day in March 2012, he mentioned a curious proposal for a tether from Mars-Phobos Lagrange to Phobos. It seemed of questionable utility, but it got him thinking about Phobos. Specifically about the possible resources of Phobos and Deimos.
We started brainstorming about it and suddenly we had a marvelous background for near-future history stories about manned space exploration. We called it "Cape Dread" after the English translation of the word "Deimos."
The concept hinged on two factors:
- Space exploration and industrialization is not going to grow until you can avoid lugging your propellant up Terra's gravity well. Easiest route is to use in-situ resource utilization, specifically for water ice.
- The delta V costs to go from Terra to Luna and back is only 1 km/s less than the delta V cost to go from Terra to Deimos and back (19 km/s as opposed to 20 km/s).
Deimos is tidally locked into a synchronious orbit with respect to Mars. Just like Luna the same side always faces the primary. The "Sub-Mars" point is the one closest to Mars. In these views, an orange light was place in the direction of Mars and a dark blue light was placed on the opposite side. So an astronaut in any orange area should be able to see Mars in the Deimosian sky.
In the following, some of the suggestions are from Rob Davidoff and others are from Yours Truly Winchell Chung. I'm not going to bother distinguishing who said what since I figure you could care less.
Rob mentioned the proposal for a tether from Mars-Phobos Lagrange to Phobos, and noted it was interesting but had no advantage over conventional rockets. But it got him thinking about Phobos. Back of the envelope calculations suggested that if Phobos was a mix of water ice and the same material as Mars, Phobos' density of 1900 km/m3 would suggest it was a whopping 68.9% water ice! Or if Phobos has large subsurface bubbles, those voids make up 28% of the volume.
Either of which would make Phobos quite valuable, as either a source of water ice or as a ready-made colony/base site with free radiation shielding and low delta V transit cost. And it could be both. Water ice and a few cubic kilometers of volume? You could fit an entire civilization inside there. Who needs RGB Mars when you have Phobos?
And this would be already on top of the gravity well, "halfway to anywhere" so to speak. It could be the key to the outer solar system.
Yes, there is ice at the Lunar poles, but that's at the bottom of Luna's gravity well. And starting from LEO, it actually takes less delta V to go to Deimos than to go to the Lunar Poles.
|delta-V for Transfers from LEO|
|Locale to LEO||LEO to Locale|
|Locale||delta-V||Trip Time||delta-V||Trip Time|
|Lunar Base||6.2 km/s||3 days||3.2 km/s||3 days|
|Deimos||5.6 km/s||270 days||1.8 km/s||270 days|
In the table below the spacecraft is assumed to be using chemical propulsion and the Oberth effect:
|LEO||Mars transfer orbit||4.3|
|Terra escape velocity (C3=0)||Mars transfer orbit||0.6|
|Mars transfer orbit||Mars capture orbit||0.9|
|Mars capture orbit||Deimos transfer orbit||0.2|
|Deimos transfer orbit||Deimos surface||0.7|
|Deimos transfer orbit||Phobos transfer orbit||0.3|
|Phobos transfer orbit||Phobos surface||0.5|
|Mars capture orbit||Low Mars orbit||1.4|
|Low Mars orbit||Phobos||1.4|
|Low Mars orbit||Deimos||1.9|
|Low Mars orbit||Mars surface||4.1|
|EML-1||Mars transfer orbit||0.74|
|EML-2||Mars transfer orbit||0.74|
|Mars transfer orbit||Low Mars Orbit||2.7|
|Terra escape velocity (C3=0)||Closest NEO||0.8–2.0|
There will probably be an orbital propellant depot at either Earth-Moon-Lagrange-1 (EML1) or EM2.
From Earth-Moon-Lagrange-1 (EML1), Mars transfer costs 0.74km/s. Mars capture costs 0.9km/s and the move to low Mars orbit costs 1.4km/s. Trip total is just over 3km/s.
Put an orbital propellant depot in Low Mars Orbit, and supply it with ice from Phobos and/or Deimos. Remember that Rick Robinson noticed that with access to an orbital propellant depot, most cis-Lunar and Mars missions are well within the delta-V capabilities of a sluggish chemical rocket engine, no nuclear rockets needed.
For that matter, shipping water from the Lunar poles to a propellant depot at either EML1 or EML2 takes 2.52 km/s of delta-V. Shipping water from Low Mars Orbit to EML1 or EML2 takes 3.04 km/s, which is only 20% more. So if it cost lots less to mine ice at Deimos compared to Luna, it might be cheaper to supply Terra's propellant depots from Deimos.
The heading of the table below are explained here.
The main thing I see in the table above is that a spacecraft with a maximum delta-V of 6 km/s starting from Terra cannot reach any of the asteroids. But if they travel to Deimos first and refuel, they can reach the asteroids easily.
From the standpoint of a science fiction writer or science fiction game designer this would be several orders of magnitude better than a puny little planetary colony or an L5 station like Babylon 5. Phobos docks, ice miners, longshoremen, local 235 ice-miner's union, a set of docking rings sort of sticking up from the ground where NTR spacecraft dock nose first in the microscopic gravity (have to hold a 1 kiloton spaceship, no weight but full inertia). Giant traffic control complex to keep the ships from colliding. Ship repair docks. Warehouses for merchant cargo in transit along with factors for various merchant corporations. Trans-ship point from the Terra-bound clippers to the reusable Mars shuttles. A place for independent asteroid miners to sell their hard found ore.
Tourist traps, luxury hotels. Not to mention the pawn shops, clip joints, bars and brothels that spring up around any spaceport or space station, in other words "Startown". Perhaps repo men ready to seize ships where the captain/owner has gotten too far behind on the ship's mortgage payment. The Phobos Port Authority would of course need a security squad. And there may be Lurkers.
PhobosPort would probably want to stay independent from Mars since free ports can make more money. There could evolve a similar situation to that found in the movie Casablanca. Various national governments (both on and off Terra) would want to seize control of the lucrative port. Meanwhile PhobosPort would be doing all sorts of shenanigans to maintain independence. It might end up corporation-dominated: Phobos Port Authority, Inc, a wholly owned subsidiary of the United Launch Alliance. Or it could start off corporate-dominated and undergo a revolution, like in the wargame Battlefleet Mars. And maybe the mayor could be Elon Musk, laughing all the way to the bank at all the short-sighted naysayers who dismissed the idea of actually making money from space. This is along the lines of the "If You Build It, They Will Come" scenario.
Now that's a setting. All based on the value of strategically located ice. There are eight million stories in the Naked Asteroid, this has been one of them...
PhobosPort was not a catchy enough name, so I suggested "Port Fear", based on the English meaning of "Phobos". Rob changed it to "Cape Fear". Cape Canaveral, Cape of Good Hope, Cape Fear ... it just fits.
Technically they'd only own the installation itself, due to the terms of the Outer Space Treaty. So they would charge for the service of mining the ice and pumping it into your propellant tanks. Any pilot who does not want to pay for the service is handed a shovel and told to do it themself.
There might also be wildcat Phobians setting up shop with their own ice processing gear in smaller internal bubble-caves. Old spacecraft too broken down to make the run back to Terra might be retired to serve as surface facilities. Break off the propellant tanks to melt'em down for metal, bury the habitat modules in regolith for protection, take the reactor and use it as a power generator. Use a Mylar bubble mirror with the dilute Martian sunshine to slowly crack water into hydrogen and oxygen, subsist on a diet of algae. And you'd have a habitat shack for an eccentric outer space mountain man. The Old Rocket Bar might actually be an old rocket.
Sadly, the eccentric mountain men will be a brutal experiment for everybody to find out exactly what the bare minimum is needed to survive in space. The crazy old coot hermits will empirically discover, the hard way, what is vital when living alone in your own cave.
Tony Zuppero called water-ice "Rocket-Fuel Ore". You melt it, you split it into oxygen and hydrogen by electrolysis. How hard is this?
Figure that the ice comes out of the ground at a chilly -100° C. It has to be heated to 22° to become liquid. Ice takes 2.1 J/gram to raise one degree C. So to get it to melting takes 210 J/gram. Then it needs an additional 334 J/gram to melt (the enthalpy of fusion). Finally another 20° at the specific heat of water at 4.182 J/gram per degree. So the total to turn our rocket-fuel ore into liquid water is about 627,000 joules per kilogram (627 kJ/kg).
Now we need energy to split the water into oxygen and hydrogen. Takes 237.13 kJ of electricity per mole of water. 1 mole of water is about 18.0152 grams, so 1 kilogram of water has 55.55 moles. So the electrolysis energy is a whopping 13,000 kJ/kg!
Grand total is 13,627 kJ or 13,627,000 joules. That's a lot. But this is about the same energy you get in the rocket engine by burning oxygen and hydrogen (less the ice melting energy). Everything has to balance. You are taking water and putting the energy into it that will later come blazing out when the oxygen and hydrogen is burned in the rocket engine.
So if a base had a 250 kW power plant devoted to melting/electrolysis of ice, and an unlimited amount of ice, in 120 days it could produce 190 metric tons of fuel (liquid oxygen and liquid hydrogen).
- 250 kW power plant = 250,000 joules per second
- 250,000 / 13,627,000 = 0.018 kilograms of ice converted to fuel per second
- 120 days = 10,368,000 seconds
- 0.018 * 10,368,000 = 190,000 kilograms = 190 metric tons of fuel
Since Phobos has microgravity, the direction of its core might not be considered "down." One might have an arrangement like the International Space Station, where the entire moon had Forward - Aft - Port - Starboard - Zenith and Nadir instead of up, down, north, south, east and west.
Stickney crater is Phobos' most impressive surface feature. Perhaps it conceals an entrance to the caves of Phobos. Or at least a shorter amount of rock to tunnel through. So operations would start there, eventually making Phobos City in the middle of Stickney. And with docked spacecraft spaced out along the rim of the crater. Initially there will be a few habitat modules inside the caves. Eventually some caves are sealed and they will start building inside the cave shirt-sleeve fashion. A crazy-quilt of structures and floatways to make an Terran civil engineer weep. More grown organically than laid out logically.
Big caverns sealed up except for a big door on the front. Surface-dock, dry-dock, and sleeve-dock. Ship that need repairs floats up. Pull the ship in and pressurize the entire cavern. With the ship owner crying as they sign the second mortgage gleefully offered by the local banker as the sleeve dock pressurizes. "Sorry about the terms to use the dock, but air ain't free, don't you know?" Dock owner swaps out the VASIMR drive, and makes a note to place an order to ULA to replenish his parts stock. Shipped from LEO to Phobos FOB. Meanwhile an engineer sees a business opportunity and opens a used propulsion system refurbishing shop. Or a engine factory. Sure it would cost more but they could corner the propulsion system market in cis-lunar space from one and a half AU away (about 227,000,000 kilometers).
The Phobos Hilton will have to have at least an observation dome, so that the guests can see the impressive view of Mars blotting out the sky. Mars will be about 42.5° or x85 the full moon on Terra.
What about the history of Cape Fear?
It would start as a waypoint for the initial Mars expeditions, the first ones that are more than flags and footprints. Stick a payload of a mining drill, filtration and pumping system plus a few habitat modules on a big LOX/LH2 stage, about a couple of hundred tons all up (minus the Earth Departure Stage (EDS) fuel). Arrive at Phobos, berth to the moon, and go to work. Pick a spot near an ice deposit. Use the drill and filtering system to reach it, and use the empty EDS tank as storage. Call it Collins Base, because the people manning it don't get to land on Mars.
One possible configuration of mission is the old Project Apex concept.
Now we wave hour hands and postulate the expedition finds MacGuffinite on Mars. Could be just the fuel on Phobos. Could be political reasons. But you need something to justify moving things to and from Mars, i.e., the establishment of a Transport Economy. In such an economy, owning the only gasoline filling station at the half-way point is a gold mine. The refilling station will allow the cargo spacecraft to increase their maximum cargo mass by about four times.
Say on Phobos they find some methane and CO2 as well as water ice. The base is expanded with another payload shipment. More drilling equipment, some laser sintering, and another large empty EDS tank for storage. They cut into one of the big caverns, sinter the walls to seal it, and use that to expand the base so it can act as a waypoint to Mars. Maybe half a cubic kilometer at first. Heh. In this report on page 12 it suggest that Kuck Mosquitoes will remove the good stuff from under the shell. Which will leave nice voids for habitat caves. The question is whether there are significant sized cavities or if the porosity is only in small volumes of less than a cubic meter or so. If the cavities are large enough, use a laser to sinter the dust and rock into an air-tight skin.
Power is a bit of a question. At that distance, solar panels only produce half of what they can crank out around Terra. So a top-of-the-line panel can generate about 125 W/m2. In direct sunlight. So a 15 megawatt solar panel will need a surface area of about 120,000 square meters (about 30 acres), could be a square about 346 meters on an edge.
Ideally you'd want a SNAP or two, but the initial base probably can't afford the expense. When Cape Fear becomes a commercial base then they'll have SNAPs. When the money starts coming in and Cape Fear can prove it is a going concern.
When the basic base is established, sooner or later somebody will realize that with a little extra investment they can turn a profit. And Elon Musk, Planetary Resources et al prick their ears up. "Profit? Did somebody say Profit?"
So Phase 1 is the initial NASA facility. Phase 2 is commercial. NASA's initial base could be by on solar power. They only need a few hundred kilowatts to harvest a few dozen tons a year. They might even be able to get by using those big half-silvered Mylar balloons instead of solar cells, which would be delightfully retro. They are lightweight and fold up real small.
The major problem with solar power in this case is that both Phobos and Deimos are tidally locked in synchronous orbit. This means solar power units on the surface of Phobos get 3.5 hours of sunlight in every 7 hours. This may mean that NASA's Phase 1 facility might need a nuclear SNAP, expensive or no. A SNAP-10a can produce 12 kW, which could split 7.6 metric tons of water ice into hydrogen and oxygen in 100 days.
As it turns out, there are some areas of both Phobos and Deimos that will stay in constant sunshine for the duration of one Martian "season" (about six Terran months) That is, you divide Mars' year (one orbit around Sol) into four seasons based on its equinox and solstices. For the duration of certain seasons Phobos and Deimos have constant sunshine areas. Presumably at other seasons the moons periodically have Sol eclipsed by Mars. Refer to the maps here.
In Phase 1, it would be something like eight to twelve astronauts in each Mars mission, with two staying on Phobos to keep the machinery running. You want to make sure that the Phobos tanks contain enough propellant for Earth Return when each mission arrives, in case an immediate abort is required.
In Phase 2, you are probably have a commercial base with a few megawatts from nuclear reactors, and a population around 600 to 3,000.
About this point Rob figured that Deimos would make more sense than Phobos. So we changed it from Cape Fear to Cape Dread. Instead of Phobians we now have Dreadheads.
Naturally, in Cape Dread, most of the furniture is going to be metal. Because there ain't no trees to supply wood. There are science fiction novels where spacecraft containing wood paneling and furniture is the height of conspicuous consumption, just to show how filthy rich you are. In his game High Frontier, Philip Eklund has his space colonists building items out of "foamed" titanium. He calls it "space wood". Plastic and ceramics also would be expensive (since they are not available locally) so replacement items made of those materials would be brought in the form of powders, 3D blueprints, and a 3D printer. Print on demand.
Actually, now that I think about it, there might be one type of wood available: Bamboo. In Martin Caidin's novel Exit Earth he sings the praises of bamboo in the space environment. As does Allen Steele in his novel Clark County, Space. Blasted stuff grows so fast it looks like you are seeing it under time-lapse photography. Three to one hundred centimeters in 24 hours. And it has a thousand and one uses. They use it in Clarke County because the space habitat needs an inexpensive, renewable supply of building material. It makes nice paper as well. Bamboo will probably grow taller in lower gravity, and since it is cultivated it would require less management than growing actual trees. Trees grow too slow anyway.
Glass might be possible to produce with locally available Demosian materials. There probably is silicon, add oxygen to make silicon dioxide, which can make a sort of slag glass. You need something transparent for solar power bubbles, domes, and whatnot.
Both Phobos and Deimos have similar composition to Carbonaceous chondrite meteors, which contain all sorts of useful elements. Including crude amino acids and other organic compounds. These are valuable as feedstocks for plastics and food. If you are thinking about a long term civilization, an important chemical is phosphorus. Isaac Asimov called it "life's bottleneck."
Asimov noted that some chemical elements are more common in the bodies of living creatures than in the rocks and dirt composing Terra. Compared to the rocks, those elements are concentrated in living things. The higher the concentration factor, the more vital that element is to organisms and the more rare the element is in rocks. By far the element with the highest concentration factor is phosphorus.
What this boils down to is that a planet's supply of living things is limited to its supply of phosphorus. It is the first thing that will run out. The point being that will also apply to a civilization living inside Deimos. If there is not enough native phosphorus it will have to be imported.
It is in Cape Dread's interest to become as completely self-sufficient as possible. Anything that must be imported is a vulnerability, a way that enemies can put the pressure on by restricting supplies. Or a survival issue if, for instance, Terra loses its heavy boost capability due to global thermonuclear war, a dinosaur-killer asteroid strike, or something equally nasty. Space is not as forgiving as Terra, it requires high technology just to breath. Air is not free. And I'm going to pointedly ignore the Three-Generation Rule as a can of worms I'd just as soon not deal with.
If Terran surface-to-orbit services can bring the boost price down to a few thousand dollars US per kilogram, that is low enough for an individual with Bill Gates or Jeff Bezos levels of wealth could create Cape Dread on their own dollar. People were joking about how James Cameron could easily spend a few million dollars with NASA to film his next space movie on location.
(ed note: in a game I was a playtester in called High Trader, each player was a "faction". Factions like "Daimler-Chrysler-Ford Aerospace", "Lockheed-Martin-Mercedes" and "Agencia Espacial Brasileira". One faction was a billionaire spaceflight junkie named after me: Kutai 'Crank' Nariji-Chung)
You'd need a few kilotons of payload from Terra delivered to Deimos. One kiloton delivered at Deimos requires 3.6 kilotons Initial Mass in Low Earth Orbit (IMLEO), assuming the LEO-Deimos delivery is by chemically powered rockets. So roughly $3.5 billion US assuming $1000/kg Terra-to-LEO boost cost. For launch only, the hardware and other payload is extra. Call it $5 billion US.
If reusable boost rockets can bring the boost cost down to $500/kg, that's only $2.5 billion US. That is doable for the super-rich. Elon Musk managed a $1.2 billion investment, and Bill Gates et al are an order of magnitude richer. It would be a multi-billionaire investing almost their entire personal wealth into it. Or a consortium of mulit-billionaires investing part of their personal wealth into it.
Imagine that there was an asteroid scare. A medium sized civilization-destroying asteroid goes whizzing by between Terra and Luna. A large near-miss (Asteroid "Close, But No Cigar"). That would be enough for a couple of billionaires to go "Huh, maybe we should get some people off-planet in case this happens again, we fail to intercept again, and this time it doesn't just miss on its own." You want to get all the eggs out of one basket. So they put down three or four billion dollars in Cape Dread, Mars, and Luna. Now of course, there's not much money in bomb shelters now that the cold war is over, and five or ten years after the near-miss things are largely back to normal, and Cape Dread and their lunar and Mars facilities have basically become a bubble and popped.But what that initial run has done is created infrastructure. This also gives an excuse of why the infrastructure might be a bit overbuild. It's not just the basic facility, it's designed to be expanded quickly if another one comes. It's basically these four or five billionaires who found their company, and then sit down with the engineers to say, "Look, that was too close. Here's a bunch of cash. Build us a base that can be expanded to house a sustainable basic population as a refuge for us and our off-shore accounts...I mean, as insurance for the human race."
In the initial boom, the Deimos corporation could offer subscriptions to billionaires. They will offer a safe place to dine on caviar while having a ring-side seat to watch all the great unwashed masses getting eradicated by the next killer asteroid. And there are other benefits, such as being a tax haven and data haven. The data transmission to and from Terra will have a 15 minute lag time, but nothing is perfect.
At that point, it doesn't matter if their reasons for investing in Cape Dread are rational ones or not. Once the infrastructure is built, the game changes. It wouldn't matter if the original founders went bankrupt. Maybe the apocalypse they were preparing for never showed up and the investors came calling. Then they sell out in bits and pieces. So Cape Dread becomes still mostly corporate owned, but not the same corporates.
if you worked the parts depot on Deimos, and you believe in the station...how much would the founders be selling assets for? Even if it's millions of dollars in spares...they're stuck at the wrong end of a 270 day trip to Terra, and mostly space-specialized. You could buy the whole stock for cheap, pennies on the dollar. Maybe scrap value plus a bit. Certainly in the price range of a worker on Deimos who had been banking all their pay because there is nothing local to spend it on. So that gives you local businessmen. Even if they still end up buying their stock from Lockheed-Boeing or SpaceX, or whatever, they own their stock there and that chunk of facilities. Because they didn't go home when McCrazy's finances crashed and the base was mothballed. They are in for the long haul. After McCrazy leaves, some of the people at Cape Dread are going to want to stay and make the place a going concern.
Don't forget about the NASA base, which was mothballed and abandoned in-place.
And then MacGuffinite is discovered on Mars, after Cape Dread been established for about 25 years now, what with the initial NASA fuel dump days, then McCrazy's multi-billion-dollar buildup. More mature, some long-term inhabitants.
So you have the old-timers vs the new reps from the companies trying to get into the picture now that MacGuffinite's on the scene...
Once you have a significant population at Cape Dread, there will arise a secondary economy.
A source for inspiration about this stage of Cape Dread's history would be Alexis Gilliland Rosinante series. The Revolution From Rosinante, Long Shot For Rosinante, and Pirates Of Rosinante. In the novels the protagonist is an engineer who was contracted to build and L5 colony in the asteroid belt. For a variety of reasons the economy of Terra slips into recession, and the colony is loses its funding. The protagonist is suddenly finds himself transformed from an engineer into the role of governor of the L5 colony. Much like we are postulating for Cape Dread.
What constitutes the MacGuffinite is a problem. It could be something on Mars, could be something on Deimos.
Maybe Dread Bourbon, made from the finest yeast culture, distilled with authentic all-natural vacuum! Imported at great expense from Deimos! The perfect way to impress all of your snob friends! ....nah, that would only be a niche market.
Deimos is a carbonaceous asteroid, unlike Luna. Luna has only trace amounts of carbon in the regolith. So Deimos is a good source of organic chemicals as feedstocks for various things. It also has some silicates, so it might make some microprocessor chips. As a "clean room" to make microchips Deimos' microgravity is an advantage over free fall. Dust dispersed in the clean room's atmosphere will eventually settle out, unlike in a space station. Carbon is also needed for carbon nanotubes.
Deimos could also supply materials to build an L5 colony, with the rest of the materials coming from Luna. I'm not saying that an L5 colony will ever be built. If the reasons for building it are plausible enough, it might be possible to fool enough rich people to invest in the project. Just long as the stupid rich people pour money into Pie-in-the-Sky-L5 to give Cape Dread enough time and resources to become at least semi-self-sufficient. Tell the rich that you are building Elysium, they'll love that. Then even if the L5 project goes bust, Cape Dread will be standing on its own two feet.
As long as Deimos has something that Luna doesn't, there is a reason for Cape Dread.
Once you have some second and third generation population, and Cape Dread is, oh, 80% self-sufficient, that might be enough. It will be self sustaining.
There will be a trickle of rich tourists visiting Cape Dread. "But Charles, everyone who is anyone has visited the Cape Dread Hilton". I'm sure the view of Mars overhead in the sky is spectacular (16.7° or x33 the full moon on Terra). For when a two-week trip to the Lunar Hilton isn't far enough away from those plebeian masses.
Since the Terran launch windows for Deimos Hohmann transfer orbits occur every 26 months (two years and two months), Cape Dread's "off season" will be in between Hohmann synodic periods. Keeping in mind that since spacecraft can refuel at Cape Dread, it is less critical to find the optimal transit. This means that the launch windows will become broader. Typically Terra-Deimos launch windows occur every 26 months and are 3 month's "wide". For example in the year 2020 you could launch from Terra to Deimos into a Hohmann transfer anytime from July 2020 to Sep 2020. Since you can refill propellant at Cape Dread, the launch window will be a few months wider than three.
If there is no cheap propellant at Terra LEO, then you'll see the trip from Terra to Cape Dread rigidly constrained by Hohmann launch windows. Fuel at LEO is either super expensive fuel boosted from Terra, or medium expensive fuel boosted from Cape Dread to LEO. In either case the price of fuel will ensure that launches to Cape Dread will be strictly by Hohmann.
Meanwhile fuel at Cape Dread will be super-cheap, much like purchasing gasoline for your automobile at the oil refinery. No fuel transport cost cost. So trips from Cape Dread to Terra might not be constrained by launch windows at all. Having said that, at the height of the "vacation" season (every 26 months when the flood of ships arrives from Terra on Hohmann trajectories), Cape Dread might raise the price on propellant. Just like any beach resort raises its prices during the vacation season, because they have you over a barrel. Perhaps groups of spacecraft owners might form a co-op in order to get a better price on propellant.
Implication: every few months ships will leave Cape Dread for Terra in order to avoid the seasonal price increase on propellant. However, the ships will gradually accumulate in LEO, since the expensive LEO propellant forces them to only launch for Cape Dread every 26 month Hohmann window. And 270 days later it is the tourist season at Cape Dread as the huge convoy of ships arrive from LEO.
Then Rob and I tried going into the timeline in more detail.
Around 2022 or so, Fobos-Grunt 2 manages to avoid being eaten by the Great Galactic Ghoul and conducts close investigation of Deimos on the way to Phobos, confirming their similar composition (except that Deimos is "fluffier"). Then when it lands on Phobos, radar and sampling confirms significant sub-regolith ice and large cavities within the body. Large amounts of volatiles are discovered.
When NASA plans a manned mission, they decide to use Phobos as an orbital propellant depot, and an orbital base for telerobotics operators to support the Mars astronauts. The gold rush is on for Phobos' propellant. NASA does one, maybe two landing to set up Collins Base on Phobos around 2030 or 2035, and three or four major missions to staff it and the Mars ground sites.
Some whiney little nation in the UN introduces a resolution to apportion the Phobos ice for all member nations, and is ignored. Much like the current Moon Treaty.
NASA is wrapping up the Mars missions when asteroid "Close, But No Cigar" comes shooting by and scares the poo out of everybody, around 2039.
This lights a fire under a group of billionaires. Call them the Exodus Foundation (est. 2040). Other billionaires start leaning on their owned politicians to increase NASA funding, to "Rescue Humanity" (translation: "Rescue Us Billionaires")
The plan is to make a second base. Not NASA, but the Exodus Foundation. By invitation only. Mostly only if you are rich enough.
So in the next six years the hardware is developed, launched into LEO, moved to Deimos, starts being set up ... and then it goes bankrupt (2046).
The work crew at Deimos is about one hundred or so, though the base is being built to handle a few thousand. In 2046 they are told to pack up and prepare to be returned to Terra. About 15 or 20 refuse to return, they are staying on Deimos. They might even file a lawsuit against the toxic assets at Deimos as compensation for unpaid back leave.
"You owe us 20 workers six years of back wages, plus hazard pay, plus early termination payout, plus transit...total of maybe a half mill each, or more. Or you can give us XYZ, theoretical worth of $1.2 billion, but auction price of right around $8 million. Because while a Morris Technologies MT5600 printer or a closed loop-life support system is worth a lot new in box on Earth....used on Deimos, return shipment not covered? Worth...less." (Some might even suggest removing the ellipse between "worth" and "less.")
So then a few years go by, the market recovers from the "slight hiccups" after the asteroid near-miss, and meanwhile the people who stayed at Cape Dread (I think they may be the ones to name it that) are fitting out the facility a bit. Rationing the stored food, expanding the horticulture, discovering the hard way what they forgot to bring, trying to find something they can trade for a "care package" mission from Terra containing whatever they forgot to bring (radio message: "Hey NASA, we have some Deimos geological data. We are willing to trade it in exchange for some stuff from you").
In a way they're lucky. The job they were sent to do was to fit this out to house roughly two orders of magnitude more people, so they have some spare supplies. The supplies will last about two orders of magnitude longer (supplies for a couple of thousand people are being used by 20 people). And stuff like the 3d printer/processor and such means they have fewer "missing pieces", provided they can get it all working and keep it that way. First order of business is to use the printer to clone the printer.
In 2055 someone decides to do some L5 colonies, maybe it's an eco-group trying to prove self-sufficiency, planning to export knowledge workers, maybe its some billionaires, maybe it's...I dunno. Maybe all of the above. This is the start of the Lagrange station boom, taking advantage of the infrastructure and tech left over from the Exodus Foundation bubble of 2040-2045. They need fuel for orbital transfers, they need raw materials, they need a lot of stuff. And though it's 270 days away, Cape Dread is the "nearest" source in terms of delta-V. So they contract Cape Dread to supply some vital raw materials. Giving Cape Dread some vital capital to purchase desperately needed items, and to upgrade their industrial base. And to import labor. 20 people isn't enough of a base staff. Not if they want to buy silicon, fuel, and products by the kiloton. Cape Dread really starts taking off about 2058.
Somewhere along the line it becomes lucrative enough that SpaceX or somebody starts up a LEO-Cape Dread passenger service. Or it may be incidental on the cargo transit. You don't want the cargo ships returning to Cape Dread to be empty, now do we?
So in 2063 is where Cape Dread goes from two main docks (slips?) to three or four, and expands to a population of a few hundred, plus another thousand-odd temp worker. Their children are in their early teens. Cargo to Mars may end up fairly cheap. If a ship is designed to carry 200 tons of fuel and mixed goods back, then an extra couple of tons on the way over is cheap. After a while, somebody wants to, say, stage an expedition the asteroid belt, and they contract Cape Dread for some refueling. Cape Dread will want to create its own gasoline service-station industry, offering maintenance and repair services in addition to just fuel. Eventually Cape Dread will purchase or make its own cargo ships. Then the secondary industries start appearing.
|Satellites of Mars|
|Periapsis||9,234.42 km||23,455.5 km|
|Apoapsis||9,517.58 km||23,470.9 km|
|9,376 km||23,463.2 km|
(7 h 39.2 min)
|0.31891 days||1.26244 days|
|2.138 km/s||1.3513 km/s|
|Dimensions||27 × 22 × 18 km||15 × 12.2 × km|
|13.4 km||7.5 km|
|11.2667 km||6.2 km|
|9.2 km||5.2 km|
|1,548.3 km2||495.1548 km2|
|Volume||5,783.61 km3||999.78 km3|
|Mass||1.0659×1016 kg||1.4762×1015 kg|
|1876 kg/m3||1471 kg/m3|
|11.39 m/s||5.556 m/s|
|Temperature||≈233 K||≈233 K|
Water is one of the most useful substances available in space. It can be electrolytically split into oxygen and hydrogen for use as chemical rocket fuel or hydrogen for nuclear thermal rocket propellant, astronaut breathing mix or later use in regenerative fuel cells. Water can be used straight (instead of hydrogen) by a nuclear thermal rocket, abet with a performance penalty. It can be used to create hydrogen peroxide, which is a rocket monopropellant. It can be drunk by astronauts, fed to hydroponically grown plants, used as coolant, or used as radiation shielding.
Currently it costs about $5000 US per kilogram to boost something into orbit from Terra. It would be an incredible savings if one could find water or water ice already in space.
As the delta-V for a mission goes up, the amount of propellant required goes up exponentially (or looking at it another way: the amount of payload shrinks exponentially). Large amounts of propellant are expensive, but the higher the mass-ratio the higher the likelihood that the spacecraft will not be resuable. Propellant expense is bad enough, but that's nothing compared to having to build a new spacecraft for each mission. Increasing the mass ratio means things like making the walls of the propellant tanks thin like foil, and shaving down the support members so they are fragile like soda straws. With such flimsy construction it does not take much normal wear-and-tear to turn the spacecraft into junk.
Having a propellant depot at the mid-point of a round-trip mission cuts the required delta-V in half. Instead of the spacecraft having to lug enough propellant to go to Mars then return to Terra, it only carries enough for half the trip but re-fuels (re-propellants, or re-remasses) at the halfway point. And when you are dealing with exponential growth, cutting the delta-V in half cuts the propellant amount much more than half.
So one needs a source of water ice, something to mine the ice, and tankers and lighter to keep the depots filled up. Examples of tankers include Kuck Mosquitos, Zuppero Water Ships, and Zuppero Lunar Water Trucks.
If your orbital propellant depot is located in Low Earth Orbit (LEO), the closest hydrated body in delta V terms is Deimos. It its closer than ice frozen in the Lunar poles (the 3 km/s take off delta V is very expensive), and it is a zillion times closer than Terra. Deimos also does not require high thrust rockets for soft landings and high energy take-offs, as is the case with Luna.
The drawback to Deimos over Luna is that launch windows to Deimos occur only every 26 months (two years and two months), and the transit time is 270 days (nine months).
However, since spacecraft can refuel at Deimos, it is less critical to find the optimal transit. So the launch windows will be wider.
For more details about the economics of Deimosian ice, see The Deimos Water Company by David Kuck. Yes, the same scientist who came up with the Kuck Mosquito concept.
Phobos and Deimos are both thought to have water ice, with Deimos ice being closer to the surface (depth of 100 meters at the equator and at a depth of 20 meters at the poles). Deimos also takes less delta V to reach than Phobos. Both Phobos and Deimos are in synchronous orbit.
|delta-V for Transfers from LEO|
|Locale to LEO||LEO to Locale|
|Locale||delta-V||Trip Time||delta-V||Trip Time|
|Lunar Base||6.2 km/s||3 days||3.2 km/s||3 days|
|Deimos||5.6 km/s||270 days||1.8 km/s||270 days|
|Mars||4.8 km/s||270 days||5.7 km/s||270 days|
Phobos and Deimos have spectra, albedoes, and densities similar to C-type or D-type asteroids. They are composed of rock rich with carbonaceous material. They probably contain hydrated (water-containing) minerals, and may have deposits of water ice in their interiors.
Table 2. Hypothetical cash flow for the project using the drill rig vehicle presented in "Exploitation of Space Oases" at Princeton in 1995. This uses nine of the original twelve drill rig vehicles.
|Proposed cash flow - 12 initial vehicles|
|Development & Construction|
|Drill & Vehicle @ $12.5m||x3|
|Launches @ $70m Sea Launch|
|Launches @ $60m Proton|
|General Expense Estimate||$10m||$10m||$10m||$10m||$10m||$10m||$10m||$10m|
|External tank to Mir||$10m||$10m|
|Total Hardware Expenses||$10m||$10m||$10m||$257.5m||$10m||$185m||$20m||$10m|
|Interest @ 20%||$2m||$4.4m||$7.3m||$60.2m||$74.3m||$128.1m||$155.8m|
|Grand Total Expenses||$10m||$22m||$36.4m||$301.2m||$371.4m||$630.7m||$778.9m||$944.7m|
|100 tonnes Deimos/Phobos @$8k/kg||$800m|
|200 tonnes Deimos/Phobos @$6k/kg||$1,200m|
|Total Gross Income Estimate||$800m||$1,200m|
|Accumulated Net Profit||$169.2m||$1,055.3m|
|Deimos versus Phobos|
|Mars Arrival (2033) plus Earth return (2035) ΔV||~2.9 km/s||~3.3 km/s|
|Two-way speed of light lag to nadir point on Mars||0.134 s||0.040 s|
|Max visible Mars latitude (with 5° elevation mask)||77.6°||64.8°|
|Fraction of Mars surface visible||97.5%||90.5%|
|Duration of comm line-of-sight to asset on Mars equator||59.6 hrs||4.2 hrs|
|Gap between comm passes to equatorial asset on Mars||71.8 hrs||6.9 hrs|
|% time a typical Mars surface site is in view||45%||38%|
|Max eclipse duration||84 min||54 min|
|Typical nighttime duration||15.1 hrs||3.8 hrs|
|Max eclipse % of orbit period||4.6%||12.0%|
|Max continuous lighting duration in Northern hemisphere||~300 days||~140 days|
|Average eclipse season duration||~83 days||~228 days|
|Max continuous lighting duration in Southern hemisphere||~225 days||~95 days|
Advantages of Deimos:
- Round trip ΔV from Earth to Deimos is about 400 m/s lower than to Phobos
- Longer communication access to assets on Martian surface
- Communciation access to higher Martian latitudes
- Superior line-of-sight to Earth from Deimos due to fewer Martian occultations
- Twice as much time with constant sunlight and only a third of the eclipse season duration as Phobos
Advantages of Phobo:
- The gap between comm passes to Martian surface assets is much shorter
- Phobos is closer to the Martian surface, resulting in higher data rates or smaller antenna & power
- The maximum possible eclipse duration is 30 minutes shorter on Phobos
- Phobos appears to be more geologically interesting than Deimos
- Sample return to Phobos is easier from low latitude Mars sites